Adam Nicolson on Chalk-Stream Salmon

In March 2023, the distinguished writer Adam Nicolson told a rapt audience in Cambridge about a recent encounter with chalk-stream salmon. Owned by Everyone is hugely grateful to Adam for sharing his account of that strange meeting, which is published here for the first time.

When salmon at sea in the English Channel come near the coast, making their way back to breed after their years out in the feeding grounds of the North Atlantic, they taste the river waters to which they are drawn. Most seem relatively unchoosy: there is little genetic distinction between those that go to rivers in the far south-west of England and those that head across the Channel to Brittany or Normandy. For those fish, it seems, almost any river will do. 

But there is one group that is different. Almost without exception the salmon born in the rivers that have flowed over the chalk of southern England will not enter a river of any other kind. It is chalk water that draws them in and as a result chalk-stream salmon are genetically distinct from all others, their uniqueness preserved by this habit of constancy and a life-long commitment to the wonders of the chalk stream. 

Imprinted in their memories are all the qualities of their particular water: alkaline, full of dissolved minerals but with almost no sediment load, reaching the sea over many miles of clean flint gravel bed, derived from springs that emerge from deep aquifers in the rock, running through valleys fringed with water mint and water forget-me-not, often thick with life-sheltering weed, not subject to the flashes and surges of rivers that run over harder rocks, but flowing steadily south through the parklands, villages and water meadows of the English chalk country.

At Testwood, on the outskirts of Southampton, the River Test, the greatest, most famous and most expensive of all England’s chalk streams, reaches saltwater. Beneath the overhanging alders, the tide floods in from the estuary and comes up against the pilings of the reinforced banks. Any migratory fish are held in the pool below the river hatches, waiting for the water to rise. Only as it comes to the top of the tide will they make their way upstream into the channels of the river itself. 

Peter Farrow, the Head River Keeper here, lives with his family beside the pool in the kind of perfect red brick Regency cottage Jane Austen would have felt happy in.  ‘It is the best ghillie’s house in the country,’ he says. ‘Even now I still pinch myself thinking I’m in a dream. And someone’s paying me to do this.’

As we sat drinking his tea, sea-trout fresh in from the Atlantic were coming up and out of the water beside us and smacking back on to the surface of the pool.  What do you feel when you hear that? I asked him. ‘I’m at home,’ he laughed. ‘When I first came here, I remember it was June. It was a hot night and that top corner room there, that was my bedroom at the time. I had the window open, the tide came up like this. This still quietness. Just like this. And then you hear it: b-dash, b-dash, b-dash. The fish were jumping all over the place. It was bouncing. I had to shut the window because they were keeping me up.’

Beside the only place in England where wild sea fish migrating inland have a way of interrupting a good night’s sleep, Peter showed me his salmon: deep in the pool, a few feet down, four or five cool, silvery-white bodies, their backs just darkened, each about three foot from head to tail, waiting for the tide. Sea-formed, swaying creatures, their muscled bodies wafting in the current below the hatches. Each of them 12 pounds or so, born in the chalk waters and now returning to them. 

Adam Nicolson has written books about places, poetry and history. He is married with five children and lives on a small farm in Sussex. One recent book, Life Between the Tides, described his making of three small rockpools on the coast of Argyll and the lives of some of the creatures that came to occupy them; another, How to Be: Life Lessons from the Early Greeks, was published in 2023. Adam’s article on chalk streams appears in the May 2024 issue of National Geographic Magazine.

By way of postscript, Adam writes: ‘I do know that if England itself were ever to wear a crown, it would be made of chalk-stream water.’

Making something happen: our rivers, our voices

‘Owned by everyone’: in the words he gave an endangered salmon smolt in a fund-raising poem written in 1985, Poet Laureate Ted Hughes had no doubts about our collective responsibility for the life of our rivers. A year after the second of the Cambridge conferences those words inspired, here’s a request as eloquent as it is urgent. Poets of all ages, our chalk streams need you!

Please share this beautiful image, the song it sings, the invitation it contains, with anyone you know who loves a chalk stream, along with the details of the competition to find two Chalk Stream Laureates, which you can find at http://chalkstreampoet.net/ — the site contains information for teachers as well as individuals. The deadline for poems is Friday 31 May; medals will be presented and winners (one under 18, one over 18) announced on 18 June at the Houses of Parliament, in the week that Sarah Green, MP for Chesham and Amersham, brings her own Private Member’s Chalk Streams (Protection) Bill to the House of Commons. The initiative is the brainchild of poet and teacher Juliet Nolan, who posts on X as @MPforNature; Juliet will be joined by judges Robert Macfarlane, Linda Newbery and Mark Wormald.

*

Poets and teachers will surely find further inspiration, as well as a brilliant overview of the crisis our chalk streams face in Adam Nicolson’s powerful new article in National Geographic Magazine, sumptuously illustrated with photographs by Charlie Hamilton James. It’s a compelling overview of the hydrology, natural history and recent human abuse of these astonishing and fragile ecosystems. The horrifying impact of continuing over-abstraction and pollution, permitted for too long by ‘a political system that puts cheap tap water before river health’, as Adam puts it, is set besides reasons to be cheerful: with the care, dedication, and understanding of a growing number of community groups, and the expertise of individuals such as Simon Cain and Charles Rangeley-Wilson, river restoration projects can bring new life in abundance to the chalk streams.

Photo: Charlie Hamilton James

*

A brilliant case study in the beauty and vulnerability of chalk streams, in all the complexity of their natural and human history, Tony Eva’s film ‘Pure Clean Water: the Chalk streams crisis in Greater Cambridge’, trailed last year during our conference, has now been released to deserved acclaim. It’s been screened in and around Cambridge in recent months, but the story it tells with quiet passion and precision deserves to provoke discussion and action wherever the competing needs and priorities of housing developers, water companies, town planners, conservationists and the life of a river come together. You can watch a trailer here:

Visit https://purecleanwater.film for details of screenings, local river groups, and to contact Tony.

*

And why not also head for the imminent UK River Summit and Festival? After a successful This takes place at Morden Hall on the River Wandle on 21st May. Claire Zambuni, its founder, has assembled an impressive array of speakers, from CEOs of Water Companies to their scourge, Feargal Sharkey, with leading voices from the Wild Trout Trust, Activist Anglers, Surfers against Sewage, Fish Legal and more. Under the banner ‘Communication and Collaboration: the key to environmental solutions’, the River Summit and Festival has set itself an ambitious agenda. Click here for details of the programme for the day and tickets.

*

Anyone who has heard Adam Nicolson describe his encounter with the marvellous, mysterious chalk stream salmon deep in the tidal river Test — a genetically distinct taxon, they have a claim to be Britain’s oldest animal — or who has been lucky enough to watch or even catch and release an Atlantic salmon, will have despaired at the confirmation provided by the IUCN at the tail end of last year that the main UK population of this extraordinary species is now officially endangered. The IUCN reassessment of the Atlantic salmon was funded thanks to our friends and partners at WildFish: you can read their press release here.

WildFish’s continuing campaigns to end open net salmon aquaculture and to take salmon off the table, as well as holding our politicians and regulators to account, continue to demonstrate the kind of determined, imaginative and resourceful activism to which despair needs to yield. We thank them for all they do.